Jump to content

John Nance Garner

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

John Nance Garner
Garner, c. 1930s
32nd Vice President of the United States
In office
March 4, 1933 – January 20, 1941
PresidentFranklin D. Roosevelt
Preceded byCharles Curtis
Succeeded byHenry A. Wallace
39th Speaker of the United States House of Representatives
In office
December 7, 1931 – March 3, 1933
Preceded byNicholas Longworth
Succeeded byHenry T. Rainey
House Minority Leader
In office
March 4, 1929 – March 3, 1931
WhipJohn McDuffie
Preceded byFinis J. Garrett
Succeeded byBertrand Snell
Leader of the House Democratic Caucus
In office
March 4, 1929 – March 3, 1933
Preceded byFinis J. Garrett
Succeeded byHenry T. Rainey
Member of the U.S. House of Representatives
from Texas's 15th district
In office
March 4, 1903 – March 3, 1933
Preceded byConstituency established
Succeeded byMilton H. West
Member of the Texas House of Representatives
from the 91st district
In office
January 10, 1899 – January 13, 1903
Preceded bySamuel Thomas Jones
Succeeded byFerdinand C. Weinert
County Judge of Uvalde County
In office
1893–1896
Preceded byA. V. D. Old[1]
Succeeded byJ. E. Cummings[2]
Personal details
Born
John Nance Garner III

(1868-11-22)November 22, 1868
Red River County, Texas, Fifth Military District, U.S.
DiedNovember 7, 1967(1967-11-07) (aged 98)
Uvalde, Texas, U.S.
Resting placeUvalde Cemetery
Uvalde, Texas, U.S.
Political partyDemocratic
Spouse
​
​
(m. 1895; died 1948)​
Children1
EducationVanderbilt University
SignatureCursive signature in ink

John Nance Garner III (November 22, 1868 – November 7, 1967), known among his contemporaries as "Cactus Jack", was an American politician and lawyer who served as the 32nd vice president of the United States from 1933 to 1941 under President Franklin D. Roosevelt. A member of the Democratic Party, Garner served as the 39th speaker of the United States House of Representatives from 1931 to 1933, having been a United States representative from Texas from 1903 to 1933. Garner and Schuyler Colfax (from 1863 to 1873) are the only politicians to have served as presiding officers of both chambers of the United States Congress as speaker of the House and vice president of the United States.

Garner began his political career as the county judge of Uvalde County, Texas. He served in the Texas House of Representatives from 1898 to 1902 and won election to represent Texas in the United States House of Representatives in 1902. He represented Texas's 15th congressional district from 1903 to 1933. Garner served as House Minority Leader from 1929 to 1931, and was elevated to Speaker of the House when Democrats won control of the House following special elections in 1931 (Republicans actually retained control immediately after the 1930 elections, but lost as several seats shifted parties).

Garner sought the Democratic presidential nomination in the 1932 presidential election, but agreed to serve as Roosevelt's running mate at the 1932 Democratic National Convention. He and Roosevelt won the 1932 election and were reelected in 1936. A conservative Southerner, Garner opposed the sit-down strikes of the labor unions and the New Deal's deficit spending. At the same time, he was considered highly effective in the passage of New Deal legislation, with Roosevelt relying greatly on Garner's wealth of political friendships and legislative skills to pilot New Deal legislation through Congress.[3] Unlike vice presidents before him, Garner also had an active, non-ceremonial role in the U.S. Cabinet.[4][5] He broke with Roosevelt in 1937 over a range of issues, especially the centralization of power in the federal government. Garner again sought the presidency in the 1940 presidential election, but Roosevelt won the party's nomination at the 1940 Democratic National Convention and chose Henry A. Wallace as his running mate.

Early life and family

[edit]

Garner was born on November 22, 1868, in a mud-chinked log cabin in Red River County, Texas, to John Nance Garner Jr. and Sarah Guest Garner.[6][7] That cabin no longer exists, but the large, white, two-story house where he was raised survives, at 260 South Main Street in Detroit, Texas.

Garner attended Vanderbilt University in Nashville, Tennessee, for one semester before dropping out and returning home. He studied law at the firm of Sims and Wright in Clarksville, Texas, was admitted to the bar in 1890,[6] and began practice in 1896 in Uvalde, Texas.[8]

In 1893, Garner entered politics, running for county judge of Uvalde County, the county's chief administrative officer. Garner was opposed in the primary by a woman—Mariette Rheiner Garner, a rancher's daughter, whom, after the election, he courted and married in 1895. Garner won, and with the Democratic nomination seen as tantamount to election in the post-Civil War Solid South, was elected county judge and served until 1896.[9][10]

Texas politics

[edit]

Garner was elected to the Texas House of Representatives in 1898 and reelected in 1900. During his service, the legislature selected a state flower for Texas. Garner fervently supported the prickly pear cactus, and thus earned the nickname "Cactus Jack". The bluebonnet was ultimately chosen.

Garner also drafted a resolution that would have divided Texas into five states. It passed the Texas House but was vetoed by the governor.[10]

Main article: Disfranchisement after Reconstruction era

In 1901, Garner voted for the poll tax, a measure passed by the Democratic-dominated legislature to make voter registration more difficult and reduce the number of minority and poor voters on the voting rolls.[11] This disfranchised most minority voters until the 1960s, and ended challenges to Democratic power; Texas became in effect a one-party state.[12]

Garner traveled parts of southern Texas controlled by the patrón system, currying political favor with the land bosses who exercised near-complete control of the local people and local elections. His patrón allies created a gerrymandered district for him, the 15th congressional district, shaped in a narrow strip reaching south to include tens of thousands of square miles of rural areas.[13]

House of Representatives

[edit]

Garner was first elected to the United States House of Representatives in 1902. He was elected from the district 14 subsequent times, serving until 1933. His wife was paid and worked as his private secretary during this period. Throughout his career he maintained allegiance to the white landowners who controlled the voting booths in South Texas. He regarded his Mexican voting base as "inferior and undesirable as U.S. citizens."[13]

Garner was chosen to serve as minority floor leader for the Democrats in 1929, and in 1931 as Speaker of the United States House of Representatives, when the Democrats became the majority.[14][15]

Vice presidency (1933–1941)

[edit]
Alternate portrait of Garner, c. 1930s

In 1932, Garner ran for the Democratic presidential nomination. It had become evident that Franklin D. Roosevelt, the governor of New York, was the strongest of several candidates, but although he had a solid majority of convention delegates, he was 87.25 votes short of the two-thirds required for nomination. After Garner cut a deal with Roosevelt, thus allowing Roosevelt to win the nomination, Garner became his vice-presidential candidate.

Garner was re-elected to the 73rd Congress on November 8, 1932, and on the same day was also elected Vice President of the United States. On February 8, 1933, then-vice president Charles Curtis announced the election of his successor, House Speaker Garner, while Garner was seated next to him on the House dais. He was the second man, Schuyler Colfax being the first, to serve as both Speaker of the House and president of the Senate. Garner was re-elected vice president with Roosevelt in 1936, serving in that office in total from March 4, 1933, to January 20, 1941.

Like most vice presidents in this era, Garner had little to do and little influence on the president's policies. He famously described the vice presidency as being "not worth a bucket of warm piss" (for many years, this quote was bowdlerized as "warm spit").[16] Historian Patrick Cox traces the possible origin of this quote to a 1960 conversation with Lyndon B. Johnson, who consulted Garner on John F. Kennedy's offer to run for vice president.[17]

During Roosevelt's second term, Garner's previously warm relationship with the president quickly soured, as Garner disagreed sharply with him on a wide range of important issues. Garner supported federal intervention to break up the Flint sit-down strike, supported a balanced federal budget, opposed the Judiciary Reorganization Bill of 1937 to "pack" the Supreme Court with additional judges, and opposed executive interference with the internal business of the Congress.[18]

During 1938 and 1939, numerous Democratic party leaders urged Garner to run for president in the 1940 presidential election. Garner identified as the champion of the traditional Democratic Party establishment, which often clashed with supporters of Roosevelt's New Deal. The Gallup poll showed that Garner was the favorite among Democratic voters, based on the assumption that Roosevelt would defer to the longstanding two-term tradition and not run for a third term. Time characterized him on April 15, 1940:

Cactus Jack is 71, sound in wind & limb, a hickory conservative who does not represent the Old South of magnolias, hoopskirts, pillared verandas, but the New South: moneymaking, industrial, hardboiled, still expanding too rapidly to brood over social problems. He stands for oil derricks, sheriffs who use airplanes, prairie skyscrapers, mechanized farms, $100 Stetson hats. Conservative John Garner appeals to many a conservative voter.[19]

Some other Democrats did not find him appealing. In congressional testimony, union leader John L. Lewis described him using tetrameter as "a labor-baiting, poker-playing, whiskey-drinking, evil old man".[20]

Painting of Vice President Garner, c. 1939

Garner declared his candidacy. Roosevelt refused to say whether he would run again. If he did, it was highly unlikely that Garner could win the nomination, but Garner stayed in the race anyway. He opposed some of Roosevelt's New Deal policies, most notably those related to wooing labor,[21] and on principle, opposed presidents serving third terms. However, Garner was also credited with steering a number of important bills through Congress in the crisis atmosphere of Roosevelt's first one hundred days in office and his relationship with the President would not become strained until Roosevelt's second term, when the Vice President's hopes of balancing the budget and paring New Deal programs faded.[5] He was also active in Roosevelt's Cabinet meetings on national policy and legislative strategy, which also resulted in the effective transformation of the previously ceremonial office of the U.S. vice president.[5] However, the president's "court-packing" plan of 1937 widened the rift with Garner,[5] and the final blow in their relationship came when the president attempted to purge opposition Democratic members of Congress in the 1938 elections.[5] Also, by 1940, Garner had come to support federal legislation against lynching (although probably more out of political opportunism rather than for principled reasons) which Roosevelt opposed.[22]

At the Democratic National Convention, Roosevelt engineered a "spontaneous" call for his renomination, and won on the first ballot. Garner received only 61 votes out of 1,093. Roosevelt chose Henry A. Wallace to be his vice-presidential running mate.[23]

Post vice-presidency (1941–1967)

[edit]

Garner left office on January 20, 1941, ending a 46-year career in public life. He retired to his home in Uvalde for the last 26 years of his life, where he managed his extensive real estate holdings, spent time with his great-grandchildren, and fished. Throughout his retirement, he was consulted by active Democratic politicians and was especially close to Roosevelt's successor, Harry S. Truman.

On the morning of Garner's 95th birthday, November 22, 1963, President John F. Kennedy called to wish him a happy birthday. This was several hours before Kennedy's assassination. Dan Rather stated that he visited the Garner ranch that morning to film an interview with Garner.[24]

Personal life and death

[edit]
Garner's grave in Uvalde Cemetery

Garner and Mariette Rheiner met and began dating after the primary election in 1893. They married in Sabinal, Texas, on November 25, 1895. Mariette served as her husband's secretary throughout his congressional career, and as Second Lady of the United States during her husband's tenure as vice president. Their son, Tully Charles Garner (1896–1968), became a banker and businessman. Garner died of a coronary occlusion on November 7, 1967, 15 days before his 99th birthday. Garner remains the longest-lived Vice President of the United States in history.[25]

Legacy

[edit]
Garner Museum in Uvalde, Texas

Garner State Park, located 30 miles (48 km) north of Uvalde, bears his name, as does Garner Field just east of Uvalde. The women's dormitory at Southwest Texas Junior College in Uvalde bears his wife's name. John Garner Middle School, located in San Antonio's North East Independent School District, is also named after him.

Garner and Schuyler Colfax, vice president under Ulysses S. Grant, are the only two vice presidents to have been Speaker of the House of Representatives prior to becoming vice president. As the vice president is also the president of the Senate, Garner and Colfax are the only people to have served as the presiding officer of both houses of Congress.

See also

[edit]

Footnotes

[edit]
  1. ^ Biennial report of the Secretary of State of Texas, December 1892
  2. ^ Biennial report of the Secretary of State of Texas (1897)
  3. ^ "John N. Garner (1933–1941)". Miller Center. Retrieved May 29, 2022.
  4. ^ "Vice Presidency". CQ Researcher. Retrieved May 29, 2022.
  5. ^ a b c d e "Garner the Vice President (1933–1941)". Briscoe Center for American History. Archived from the original on May 12, 2021. Retrieved May 12, 2021.
  6. ^ a b "John Nance Garner, 32nd Vice President (1933-1941)". Retrieved October 23, 2017.
  7. ^ Lionel V., Patenaude (June 15, 2010). "Garner, John Nance". Texas State Historical Association. Retrieved March 27, 2018.
  8. ^ Anders, Evan (February 11, 1987). Boss Rule in South Texas: The Progressive Era. University of Texas Press. p. 106. ISBN 978-0-292-70763-4.
  9. ^ "GARNER, John Nance | US House of Representatives: History, Art & Archives". history.house.gov. Retrieved January 22, 2023.
  10. ^ a b Neal, Steve (July 6, 2004). Happy Days are Here Again: The 1932 Democratic Convention, the Emergence of FDR - and How America Was Changed Forever. Harper Collins. p. 83. ISBN 0-06-001376-1. Retrieved January 13, 2023.
  11. ^ "Nixon v. Condon. Disfranchisement of the Negro in Texas", The Yale Law Journal, Vol. 41, No. 8, June 1932, p. 1212, JSTOR 791091 accessed 21 March 2008
  12. ^ Texas Politics: Historical Barriers to Voting, accessed 11 Apr 2008 Archived April 2, 2008, at the Wayback Machine
  13. ^ a b Minutaglio, Bill (2021). A Single Star and Bloody Knuckles: A History of Politics and Race in Texas. University of Texas Press. pp. 68–69. ISBN 9781477310366.
  14. ^ "The Opening of the 72nd Congress | US House of Representatives: History, Art & Archives". history.house.gov.
  15. ^ Patrick Cox, University of Texas at Austin, "John Nance Garner," West Texas Historical Association joint meeting with the East Texas Historical Association at Fort Worth, February 26, 2010
  16. ^ Johns, Daniel (July 1, 2012). "The Vice Presidents That History Forgot". Smithsonian. Retrieved January 3, 2017.
  17. ^ Cox, Patrick L. "John Nance Garner on the Vice Presidency—In Search of the Proverbial Bucket". Briscie Center for American History. Retrieved November 20, 2022.
  18. ^ Sean J. Savage (1991). Roosevelt, the Party Leader, 1932–1945. University Press of Kentucky. p. 33. ISBN 978-0-8131-1755-3.
  19. ^ see online
  20. ^ Time August 7, 1939
  21. ^ "John Nance Garner". Texas Monthly. November 1996. Retrieved May 12, 2021.
  22. ^ Magness, Phillip W. (July 31, 2020). "How FDR Killed Federal Anti-Lynching Legislation". American Institute for Economic Research.
  23. ^ Timothy Walch (1997). At the President's Side: The Vice Presidency in the Twentieth Century. University of Missouri Press. p. 50. ISBN 9780826211330.
  24. ^ Dan Rather, The Camera Never Blinks (1976), page 113.
  25. ^ Lewis, Janna (December 22, 2015). "Texans who were presidents, vice-presidents". Fort Hood Sentinel. Fort Hood, Texas. Retrieved December 21, 2022.

Further reading

[edit]
  • Anders, Evan. "The Election of John Nance Garner to Congress" in Anders, Boss Rule in South Texas. Austin, TX: University of Texas Press, 1982. online
  • Brown, Norman D. (2000). "Garnering Votes for "Cactus Jack ": John Nance Garner, Franklin D. Roosevelt, and the 1932 Democratic Nomination for President". The Southwestern Historical Quarterly. 104 (2): 149–188. JSTOR 30239246.
  • Champagne, Anthony. "John Nance Garner", in Raymond W Smock and Susan W Hammond, eds. Masters of the House: Congressional Leadership Over Two Centuries (1998) pp 144–80.
  • Cooper, George. "Texas, Banks, and John Nance Garner." East Texas Historical Journal 56.1 (2018): 7+ online.
  • Cox, Patrick. "John Nance Garner" in Kenneth E. Hendrickson Jr., ed. Profiles in Power: Twentieth-Century Texans in Washington (2nd ed. 2004)
  • Fisher, Ovie Clark (1982). Cactus Jack. Texian Press. ISBN 978-0-87244-066-1.
  • Patenaude, Lionel V. "The Garner Vote Switch to Roosevelt: 1932 Democratic Convention." Southwestern Historical Quarterly 79.2 (1975): 189–204. JSTOR 30238382
  • Patenaude, Lionel V. "Garner, Sumners, and Connally: The Defeat of the Roosevelt Court Bill in 1937." Southwestern Historical Quarterly 74.1 (1970): 36–51. JSTOR 30236624
  • Schwarz, Jordan A. (May 1964). "John Nance Garner and the Sales Tax Rebellion of 1932". The Journal of Southern History. 30 (2): 162–180. doi:10.2307/2205071. JSTOR 2205071.
  • Spencer, Thomas T. (January 2018). "For the Good of the Party: John Nance Garner, FDR, and New Deal Politics, 1933–1940". Southwestern Historical Quarterly. 121 (3): 254–282. doi:10.1353/swh.2018.0000. S2CID 149356041.
  • Timmons, Bascom N. Garner of Texas: A Personal History. 1948. online
  • Will, George. "In Cactus Jack's Footsteps". Jewish World Review Jan 6, 2000.
[edit]
Wikiquote has quotations related to John Nance Garner.
Wikimedia Commons has media related to John Garner.
U.S. House of Representatives
New constituency Member of the U.S. House of Representatives
from Texas's 15th congressional district
1903–1933 		Succeeded by
Party political offices
Preceded by House Democratic Leader
1929–1933 		Succeeded by
Preceded by Democratic nominee for Vice President of the United States
1932, 1936 		Succeeded by
Political offices
Preceded by House Minority Leader
1929–1931 		Succeeded by
Preceded by Speaker of the United States House of Representatives
1931–1933 		Succeeded by
Preceded by Vice President of the United States
1933–1941 		Succeeded by
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=John_Nance_Garner&oldid=1253786506"